It is often claimed that civilisation begins in certainty and the need for control. Controlling the environment, controlling the crops through agriculture, populations through power hierarchy and a general mastery over the outside world. That the rise of large-scale human settlements and societies is about managing uncertainty, resolving doubt and reducing the friction, inconvenience and anxiety of not knowing what comes next.
Nevertheless, the same concerns do not seem to have plagued one of the first borns of urban civilization, namely philosophy. Unlike us, the ancient Greeks had a high tolerance for doubt and uncertainty.
The beginning of philosophy was a celebration of doubt. Xenophanes said no one knows the truth about the gods, since opinion is “wrought over all”. For Democritus, truth lies “in an abyss”. Protagoras noted he cannot know whether the gods exist. Gorgias argued that nothing exists, or that it cannot be known or communicated, including these very statements. It appears doubt is self-defeating.
Philosophy, understood as a truth-seeking adventure, seemed like a non-starter. Not so, if considered, as many thought of it at the time, as the path towards wisdom. To be wise is to enter into conversation with doubt, and to see what happens.
Voiding doubt was not the way forward for some of the earliest thinkers in the Mediterranean tradition. Pyrro the arch-sceptic didn’t write anything, like Socrates, and treated doubt as the foundation of cognition. Things, his followers quoted him saying, are undifferentiated and undecidable, so senses and beliefs are neither true nor false. We should therefore, he argued, be unopinionated and say of each thing that it “no more is than is not”. Silence, or aphasia, follows, then tranquillity, ataraxia.
Socrates deepens the concern. His method, the elenchus, produces aporia, or no-way-forward, in his interlocutors, ending most arguments in an impasse, the coronation of doubt. In the Meno, he poses the paradox of inquiry: how can you search for what you do not know? Doubt seems to be all there is.


