In Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, a man is asked how he went bankrupt. “Gradually, then suddenly.”
Long-held ideas can change the same way.
Wycliffe’s followers produced an English Bible in the 1380s. The Church condemned it. Owning a copy was dangerous, even fatal. William Tyndale was strangled and burned in 1536 for translating the New Testament. In 1538 Henry VIII’s government ordered an English Bible into every parish church. Much of its text was Tyndale’s. An irony of biblical proportions.
Copernicus placed the sun at the centre of the cosmos in 1543. Most astronomers used his mathematics and ignored his cosmology. Bruno was burned in 1600, though cosmology was only one of the charges. Galileo was condemned in 1633. Newton published his Principia in 1687. Within a generation, most natural philosophers took the idea for granted. What had been heresy now received the badge of orthodoxy.
William Harvey argued in 1628 that the heart pumps blood around the body in a kind of a circuit. In Antiquity, Galen had taught otherwise, and that idea held for about 14 centuries. Harvey reported that his medical practice suffered. Colleagues called him a crank. By the 1650s the circulation was taught as fact. His demonstrations were simple, anyoone could bind an arm and watch the veins swell.
History looks tidier in hindsight, especially when it’s organised in neat narratives. But the people living through those changes likely saw no pattern, and predictions always fail.
The record preserves the Hemingwayesque ‘suddenly’. It might be a decree, a book, a trial or a demonstration. The ‘gradually’ part leaves few traces, if any. But it is this part that builds up in complex systems, almost always invisibly and unknowingly.
As historians, we then read the visible break as the cause. The sudden moment collects all the explanatory power. And what looks like wisdom is oftentimes just gentle foolishness.


